Monday, July 12, 2010
Knowing the Facts
Wesley Smith has been brought to Australia by the Right to Life lobby group to lobby in Tasmania, Queensland, Victoria, New South Wales, and Western Australia.
Mr Smith says Tasmanian politicians' backing for a private member's bill could end in a voluntary euthanasia law that will lead to a broader range of people being eligible for assisted suicide.
He says that in Belgium and the Netherlands legislation has been gradually eased to allow sick babies, people with mental illness and healthy spouses of terminally ill people to be euthanised.
Mr Smith says there can be no legislative roadblocks to restrict who would be eligible for assisted suicide.
"Once you accept the precepts of assisted suicide, that suffering is a just cause for helping someone to end their life, it's not going to remain restricted," he said.
"That's the argument I think we should have as a society."
In other words, Smith's not interested in dialogue, he's already laid out his argument and expects others -- despite the horrors of end of life care, four decades of technical advancements that have changed the definition of death, rampant futile care, and failing health systems across the globe -- like the Australian government to toe his line.
We can say that Smith has a right to his opinion here in the U.S. -- the First Amendment exists for a vital reason -- but he must adhere to facts, an area where he prefers to move quick and loose. But playing the ambassador to other countries, even at the invitation of religious groups that espouse broad imposition of ideological medicine on all citizens, is really offensive. Particularly when he purports to be an expert, touting the horrors of the Netherlands' and Belgium's laws and health care systems. From a man who still claims Terri Schiavo was murdered. His broad-strokes, black and white approach to bioethics is embarrassing. His use of the controversial subject and the politically, ideologically motivated "right to life" organizations to get the limelight is irresponsible. Take the "Made in America" sticker off that export.