Saturday, November 26, 2011

Hospitals and Disability in Elders

Hospitals are dangerous for elders. If you care for a hospitalized elder and can read one article that will "change for the better how you care for them," GeriPal recommends this one (From the JAMA, in which activities of daily living are given the acronym ADLs!):

In older patients, acute medical illness that requires hospitalization is a sentinel event that often precipitates disability. This results in the subsequent inability to live independently and complete basic activities of daily living (ADLs). This hospitalization-associated disability occurs in approximately one-third of patients older than 70 years of age and may be triggered even when the illness that necessitated the hospitalization is successfully treated.


Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Guns, Death with Dignity, and Moral Equivalency.

Tell me this: What's the difference between giving an elderly or disabled person a gun specifically designed for their use or giving them a lethal prescription for drugs? Either way, the licensed (and Medicaid-reimbursed) "object" can cause death of the prescribed person or others.

I would say no difference whatsoever, except for how we view personal autonomy with regards to the two lethal "objects." And the horrors of physical violence perpetrated by gun deaths. If I read one more website comment that says, "why legalize aid in dying when the determined ill patient can just end their life without approval?" I'm going to puke.

Where's Wesley J. Smith and his arguments for moral equivalency when you need him?!

The intended target market for the Palm Pistol is the elderly, the disabled, and individuals with limited strength or manual dexterity. [10] Carmel’s hope was for individuals in the target market to be able to request a prescription for the product from their physicians and be partially reimbursed by Medicare or private insurance. [11]

Matt Carmel is an NRA certified firearms instructor in New Jersey and learned that many of his clients had little experience shooting a gun. He observed that they were unable to keep the muzzle of their pistols steady, causing their shots to be inaccurate. He also found that beginning shooters have a tendency to shake because of a fear of recoil, fear of noise, and general apprehension in handling firearms. [12]

Labels: , , , , , ,

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Provider Refusal of Futile Care.

Thaddeus Pope has an intriguing post at his blog today about what can be termed the undermining of doctors' refusal of care. He cites a recent article by Christopher M. O'Connor, associate legal council for Lancaster General Hospital (where I was born), in the recent Journal of Lancaster General Hospital. The article is titled, "Can the Health Care System Ever Say No?" and addresses the lack of clear guidelines and protections for physicians who wish to end care that is not beneficial.

I have written passionately about the problems of provider refusals (so called conscience clauses) that often allow a provider -- a doctor, a denominational institution, pharmacists, etc. -- to deny services that they are morally, ethically, and most often religiously, opposed to. Twenty percent of Americans are treated in Catholic hospitals, for instance, where they are denied medical services that the Catholic Church opposes. These guidelines discriminate against women predominantly regarding reproductive services, but also against gays and the elderly. I strongly oppose this type of discrimination and see it as a violation of patients' rights.

But Connor comes at it from another angle. What about doctors who are, by emotional family members or fearful terminal patients, asked to provide care that will not prolong life? Doesn't the provider refusal law protect them from perpetuating the suffering of patients?

Jessica Mitford wrote in her 1963 bestselling expose of the funeral industry, "The American Way of Dying," that most of us are coerced into buying services and products for our deceased loved ones because we are uneducated consumers, distraught with the emotions that surround death, pressured by cultural forces that dictate a contrived form of propriety, and forced to be consumers of an industry that we know very little about.

The health care industry is not unlike the funeral industry in that we know little about it as consumers until we are forced to make use of it, often under great distress. As death and illness have become more and more institutionalized, taking place primarily outside the home, our culture has become less and less versed in how death occurs, how the medical industry operates, what choices we have in cases of terminal illness. And too, medical technology has created more choices and options, making that removed industry even harder to understand easily. We are uninformed consumers, in other words, lost, when forced to enter into the health care system, in the complications of it all. And the emotion of it all. The responsibility of making decisions is a terrible weight for the ill and their family members. Doctors are looked to as paternal, autoritarian advisors, the ones who know everything and can make the best decisions for us.

This can be detrimental in the case of a young woman who has been raped and happens to enter a Catholic hospital where state laws don't require that the emergency room workers where she is treated inform her of the existence of emergency contraception. Lives are ruined in these instances. But the other side that Connor reminds me of this morning, is when a doctor has to say to an unknowing and distraught loved one that a Do Not Resuscitate order is the very best for their loved one, a path that will cause the least amount of suffering.

In a culture where denial of death is championed, where suffering is glorified, where patients are faulted for "giving up" if they go into hospice, where fighting against death and illness is termed as a battle that requires great strength against all odds, how can we educate emotional family members and patients about how to die? And how do we equip well-intentioned doctors to not only communicate impending death but to make legal decisions about ending futile care? I don't have concrete answers. And obviously neither does the medical industry. Certainly the answers aren't to be found in the cultural stories that we are bombarded with daily by all sorts of media.

I have a hospice patient right now who is having a difficult time understanding that he is terminal. His family members and friends keep sending him cards that say "get well soon." The facility's church group come to pray for a cure for him and tell him that no miracle is too impossible for God. We had a very difficult time finding an effective pain management regiment because he was ashamed to tell the nurses when he was in pain, intimidated by their authority, and unsure of what was happening to him. He failed to understand that there is life between full function and death and that the period of disability he is entering has value -- because like the rest of us he just didn't know. He doesn't know what's coming and he has no reference to the experience in his prior 65 years. He looks to the nurses and doctors for direction; they look to him for decisions -- neither fully able to discuss the matter frankly.

Patients will only be able to make informed medical decisions when they are informed consumers. Unfortunately, so many factors impede proper informed consent. Yet I fear that strengthening provider refusals improperly limits patients' rights, taking the most important decisions out of the hands of those lives directly affected. There's nothing like informed, patient, incremental conversation to prepare a patient for what is ahead. Until doctors and society are willing and able to have those conversations, we will struggle to keep decision-making in the right hands: the patient's.

The post:

His conclusion: "Recent legal decisions have not necessarily prohibited the health care system from refusing to provide care, but they have questioned, and perhaps narrowed, the circumstances in which the medical community can refuse to provide care it believes is both ethically and medically inappropriate."

In a section titled "unsettled legal foundation," O'Connor writes: "Courts have recognized that physicians cannot be forced to provide care that is not beneficial. However, they have failed to announce concrete standards or consistent principles to guide the medical community to resolve disputes between it and patients (and their families)."

O'Connor, actually goes beyond making the point that the law is unsettled ans suggests that it is getting even less provider friendly. Citing the March 2009 Betancourt opinion, he writes that "Although courts, and in some cases, state legislatures, have shown a willingness to recognize circumstances in which the health care system can refuse to continue care that is not beneficial, recent events indicate that the tide may be turning."

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Working for Disability Rights and End of Life Rights.

Oh, I'm under fire again. This time mostly from Canadians, likely because the euthanasia bill C-384 is back in debate this week. Opponents are lashing out, even across the border. And at me for what I would consider an incredibly benign post that is all history of disability rights in Canada. Geesh.

I don't know the Canadian bill intimately, admittedly, though I have had interaction with Alex Schadenberg of the Canadian Euthanasia Prevention Coalition. I think he seems like an alright guy with a poorly-defined mission. His work is predicated on legislating his idea (of life) and death that is no longer valid and has been rapidly changing for the past 40 years. I admit that medical advancement has muddied that definition, he does not. "Go get-em" he says to Stephen at Not Dead Yet. I'm -em.

Not Dead Yet caught up with my Vancouver Sun link and dug around til they found the last time they (and "pro-lifer" Jill Stanek) wagged their fingers at me. Stephen posits that supporting Death with Dignity (the aid in dying bills in Oregon and Washington, as I do) means that I'm out to kill the disabled because, um, allowing terminally ill patients, who I admit can be classified as disabled because of their illnesses, to decide when and where to end their lives means that I have some deep-seated intent to start killing anyone that looks at me askance.

I don't mean to be flip about this, nor evasive. I've been accused of not addressing disability rights in my advocacy for end of life rights. I haven't because, while I understand the justified fear that the disabled have of state laws, and of society's and the medical profession's discrimination, I find the definition of "terminal" to not include someone in a wheelchair.

When you're accustomed to systemic discrimination, seeing your fellow-travelers is sometimes difficult. I'm advocating for patients' rights - and that means the right of every one of us, regardless of our color, class, gender, education, or functionality, to make our own medical decisions. The legalization of Death with Dignity in Washington and Oregon doesn't in any way cheapen or make vulnerable the lives of any member of society.

Yet this is the case that many make, out of fear, out of mis-directed self-defense, or out of lack of information regarding the end of life experience and the DwD laws. And this was the case that Bad Cripple made at his site yesterday, oddly lumping me with every person who's ever offended or misunderstood him:

As for the first example, I have news for Neumann: if I have learned anything in the last thirty years of using a wheelchair it is that all people with a disability are not valued to some degree. There is no slippery slope involved. Just ask any paralyzed person or anyone with a disability. Better yet go to a school board meeting and listen to one and all cluck about the need for equal access and then vote down the need for that expensive elevator or lift on the school bus. There is no over reaction here . Indeed, if disability activists are guilty of anything I would argue we are too passive. We need to be more vigorous in asserting our inalienable rights as citizens.

Comparing murder to depriving the disabled of school buses is over-reaction. Again, I agree that our society should work much harder to accommodate the disabled, to wipe away prejudices. Anything less than equality for the disabled is discrimination, plain and simple. But claiming that every supporter of Death with Dignity is out to end the lives of every disabled person is over-the-top.

As for the second example, I doubt Neumann goes through the same mental gymnastics or experience the fear people with a disability do when they go to the doctors office or hospital. Perhaps Neumann can appreciate the difference between the terminally ill and disabled but I assure you most people, doctors included, do not. How else do I explain comments made to me such as "I would be rather be dead than use a wheelchair" or "Are you sure you wish to receive medical treatment" or "How longe have you suffered paralysis?" A clear message is being sent and it is not positive. Indeed, it is deadly and with the right spin can be lethal in some circumstances. My existence is open to question, my life less valuable. This is not paranoia but rather a social fact.

I didn't make those comments, nor would I. I believe that a disabled person has the same rights to be informed of their medical status and options as anyone else. But fear of a law that applies to terminal patients and working to oppose the rights of the dying does not protect the disabled from prejudice. BadCripple's existence should never be open to question! His life is never valueless. Hideous discrimination does exist. This we must work to end.

Sacrificing the rights of some for the fears of others never works. Or every black man with a bandana on his head and his hand in his pocked would be jailed away from every prejudiced little old lady who thought he was out for her purse. In other words, fear is powerful and often justified but it cannot be used to sanction the innocent acts of others.

Somehow I doubt anyone has openly questioned the value of Nuemann's existence or asked her if she really wished to receive medical treatment. Frankly I do not want Nuemann's sympathy or anyone else's for that matter. What I want is support; support for my civil rights. That support starts at the beginning, middle and end of life. I have not had that support from anyone aside from my family, friends and doctor or two. What an indictment on society. How can something as unimportant as the ability to walk have such profound social consequences. Worse yet when I assert my rights I get called "paranoid" by people like Nuemann with a political goal--the legalization of assisted suicide. This is depressing to me and I sincerely doubt I can sway the views of people such as Nuemann. Hence this why I write more about disability rights than the politics of assisted suicide.

Asserting one's rights is not what I was calling paranoid; working to end the rights of others in order to assert oneself is reactionary. I may not be in a wheelchair but I will always support civil rights, equality and autonomy for those who are. I may not understand the kind of discrimination the disabled receive but I do know what it's like to have others legislate me out of my own health care decisions.

And here's the reply I posted at Bad Cripple, below. It's sparked a lot of productive conversation. You can read the other comments here.

My advocacy is for patients' rights. I don't know what it's like to be in a wheel chair, nor what it's like to be black or gay or old and feeble. But as a woman, I know what it's like to have my decisions about my health impeded by the government, society, and other groups. I'm not writing to offer sympathy but empathy, that quality that binds advocates to their objective of protecting individual rights in health care delivery.

What you and I disagree on is the definition of death. Until about 40 years ago, death meant the almost simultaneous cessation of breathing, heart beat and brain function. But not so today.

With respirators and defibrillators we can sustain the first two indefinitely. CPR, 911, paramedics can make our hearts beat and our lungs breath. This is a brilliant thing; yet only 15% survive resuscitation to leave the hospital.

My point is that we have the technology to sustain life but also prolong death. And so the definition of death has changed; natural death is less and less common as we are given feeding tubes, respirators, pace-makers and increased artificial means of maintaining the body. In a world where something like 75% of society says it would like to die at home, 80% die in facilities.

What does this have to do with disability? We will all be disabled at some point. By age, by disease, by other health issues. But we all deserve the ability to make our medical choices. It is this ability - this right - that I advocate for.

What Not Dead Yet, Alex Schadenberg at Euthanasia Prevention Coalition and you miss in my writing is my support for Death with Dignity as legalized in Oregon and Washington (US). DwD involves only the terminally ill with 6 months to live, of sound mind, getting a prescription from their doctor that allows them to choose when and where they die. They are dying of their disease. They are not suicidal.

This is not at all different from a family member honoring one's advance directive to remove a respirator or forgo a feeding tube, nor from a patient's choice to end experimental treatments for cancer. It is a choice for as natural a death as we can have. It is a choice to not lie in a hospital, fully sedated for the remaining 6 weeks of life.

We, as members of developed countries where life-prolonging treatments can simply keep us "alive" for longer than God's planned, must now legally struggle with this new definition of death. And we must do so in a way that honors every patient's choice. Regardless of their race, economics, age, or medical condition.

This is my advocacy: To end futile, unwanted care which prolongs suffering; to educate patients' on what their rights are; and to work to help all of us plan for the end of life so that the decisions are in our hands.

In my work for patients' rights, I'm more of a fellow traveler than, unfortunately, you realize.


Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Organ Donation and Determining When Death Starts.

Yesterday's New York Times article is titled with the loaded question, "When does death start?" and tells the sad story of a parent whose daughter is hit by a truck. The grief-stricken mother realizes that her daughter has lost all but a few basic physical reflexes and requires life support to survive. And she knows that her daughter would have agreed to organ donation.

Organ transplantation must abide by the so-called dead-donor rule: a person has to be declared dead before any vital organs can be removed. Yet organs have to be alive if there is any hope of successful transfer to a recipient. Medical professionals have handled this paradoxical situation — finding a dead body with live organs — by fashioning a category of people with beating hearts who are said to be brain-dead, usually after a traumatichead injury, and who are considered just as dead as if they had rigor mortis.

To diagnose brain death, doctors typically go through a checklist of about a dozen items, including assessing reflexes like blinking, coughing and breathing, which are all controlled by the brainstem. The criteria are extremely strict, and only a tiny fraction of severely brain-injured people meet them. Kleinman realized that Amanda, despite her severe brain damage, was not one of them. There was, Kleinman told Beaulieu, another option — one that was still controversial and had never been pursued successfully at Children’s Hospital. The procedure was called donation after cardiac death, or D.C.D., and it would exploit the other way the law defines death: as the “irreversible cessation” of the heartbeat.

D.C.D. requires doctors to confront the shadowy question of exactly when somebody dies after the heart stops. To authorize D.C.D., doctors must follow a strict procedure. Amanda would be taken, technically alive, to an operating room, where her breathing tube would be removed. If her breathing ceased naturally and her heart stopped quickly (within an hour), she would be moved to an adjacent operating room and Kleinman would count off precisely five minutes, during which time Amanda would be prepped for surgery with antiseptics and surgical drapes, while Kleinman carefully watched for signs of a returning heartbeat. If there were none, Amanda would be declared legally dead; the stoppage would then be considered “irreversible.” Before her organs were seriously damaged by the lack of oxygen (every minute counts), the surgeons would rapidly open Amanda’s torso and remove them for transplant.

The article tangentially takes up the "pro-life" accusations that determining death "arbitrarily" - in this case, 5 minutes after the heart stops - is really a contrived criteria motivated by the desperate need for organs. In many segments of society, particularly among the black community, failure to agree to organ donation, say on driver's licenses, is fueled by the fear that doctors will see the person as less than human, not worth saving, and rush them off for organ harvesting.

It's a fear that "pro-life" advocates have manipulated in recent years to fight everything from removal of artificial nutrition and hydration (the US Conference of Catholic Bishops has just changed their hospital policies to include ANH as "obligatory") to removal from respiratory machines. All life - unconscious, unrecoverable, slated for a life of machines and vegetative state - is sacred in God's eyes, they say. Doctors are playing God by deciding when a patients is dead. Never mind that doctors are playing God by keeping the patient artificially alive.

Disability rights activists too are concerned that, disability as defined as everything from blindness to frailty at end of life or vegetative state, as they advocate in order to bring more attention and normalcy to disabled states, then brings great concern to qualifications like "quality of life" and "dignity." Particularly concerning aid in dying, disabled groups fear that the medical profession and society have consistently failed to value disabled lives as worthy of advanced medicine.


The Times article give a little history of attempts to define death:


The paradox of needing a dead donor with a live body was first addressed in 1968. Henry Beecher, a Harvard anesthesiologist and medical ethicist, convened a 13-member committee to write a definition of “irreversible coma,” or brain death, for The Journal of the American Medical Association. Not everyone accepted the four-page report’s conclusions. After Norman Shumway, a Stanford University surgeon, performed the first American heart transplant from a brain-dead donor, he was threatened with prosecution by the Santa Clara County coroner. As a result of the widespread disagreement over the meaning of “brain death,” President Jimmy Carter asked a blue-ribbon commission to examine the issue. The commission culminated in the Uniform Determination of Death Act in 1981, which defined death as “irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain, including the brainstem.” The procedure to diagnose brain death, however, was never codified into law, and as a result, it varies from hospital to hospital. In 1987, the nation’s pediatrics authorities tried to standardize the diagnosis, listing 14 different criteria to confirm brain death, like the absence of reflexes, and requiring, under certain conditions, additional X-rays and tests for brain-wave activity. Last year, in the journal Pediatrics, researchers from Loma Linda University reported that of 277 brain-dead children in California who were referred to the regional organ bank over many years, only a single child received the full set of diagnostic tests.

The writer of the story, Darshak Sanghavi, a pediatric cardiologist at University of Massachussetts Medical School, gets at the controversy surrounding the determination of death and the harvesting of organs by citing a recent case:

As Gary Greenberg wrote in The New Yorker, donating organs in such a manner, deliberately and with anesthesia, could simply be “a particular way to finish our dying, at the hands of a surgeon, after some uncertain border has been crossed.” But Francis Delmonico, a professor of surgery at Harvard Medical School and a national leader in organ transplantation, fervently defends the need to establish death before removing organs. “I understand a family’s anguish and inability to have consolation when a child doesn’t die after removal of life support,” he explains, “but I don’t see this as a patients’-rights issue. It’s a matter of public trust in the system.”

Donation after cardiac death already arouses suspicion. Just as transplant surgeons like Norman Shumway were once harassed for procuring organs from brain-dead donors, a California-based surgeon, Hootan Roozrokh, was tried for dependent-adult abuse, a felony, after participating in an attempted D.C.D. A nurse who objected to the proceedings later registered a complaint about how painkillers were administered to the patient. Prosecutors charged him with trying to hasten the patient’s death. Though none of this held up in court — Roozrokh was acquitted last year — the trial left many transplant surgeons shaken. Just think of the outcry, Delmonico cautions, if families and doctors also decided it was acceptable to euthanize patients to procure their organs. “You would destroy organ donation in this country,” he said.

It's an important issue and a well-written article. Though I include excerpts, I recommend you read the entire article at the link above.

UPDATE: from the conservative lifenews, an article on this NYTimes article by Judie Brown that does nothing to understand the challenges faced by parents, like those described by Sanghavi, and everything to bash parents or medical proxies in difficult positions over the head with an ideological position that has little science or medical foundation.

This is not dialogue that Brown invites, this is a law, given to her by doctrinal authority and some hefty self-righteousness, which she demands be enforced, regardless of the patient's rights, faith, particular diagnosis, or a parent's wishes. Sanghavi produced a searching article that examined the challenges medicine and patients face as technology allows here-to-fore life-saving procedures. Inability of the Right to engage in conversation regarding these very nuanced and difficult decisions and ethics will not further advance science or humane response, it will continue to mire the Right in rigid and unchanging, draconian, impossible positions that label them deniers of science and modernity. As a community, we are here to solve emerging problems together. Brown shows that the "pro-life" position may have clout, resources, soldiers, and media outlets but it still lacks compassion for human suffering. Hers is a sad and telling position-piece on obsolescence.


Labels: , , ,

Thursday, January 7, 2010

What is Disability?

As I ponder the end of life care landscape on a daily basis, I've come across the many opponents to aid in dying. Disability advocates, in many cases, have worked with "pro-life" groups in order to protest what they call the vulnerability of the disabled when aid in dying is legalized, as was just done in Montana.

This argument co-opts the "pro-life" position that aid in dying (or assisted suicide or euthanasia) is a slippery slope and holds up nations like the Netherlands, where aid in dying is legal, as example.

There are a thousand ways to parse the statistics but the statistics in the US - and the way that aid in dying has been legalized, regulated, and practiced here - do not bear out the accusations.

But the slippery slope argument makes me wonder, What is Disability? Is it frailty at the end of life? Physical or mental challenges present from birth like blindness or Downs Syndrom? Or physical challenges encountered later in life like spinal cord injuries? Brain death (as the Schindler family, Terri Schiavo's parents and siblings contest)?

Until we have a more detailed understanding of what disability is we will be left to struggle with the argument of who has the right to determine their own choices, who is "vulnerable" and what dignity or quality of life mean.

VSA Arts is running a project that asks people around the world to submit postcards that explore the definition of disability. I look forward to what they receive.

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Disability on the Rise Among Elderly for First Time in 20 Years.

Healthfinder.gov, the site of US Health and Human Services reports that disability among seniors is on the rise for the first time in 20 years, increasing by 9 percent between 2000 and 2005:

The disability rate among U.S. senior citizens is on the rise, a surprise considering the rate had been falling since the 1980s, new research has found.

"People are living longer, but many are also living sicker," study co-author Amani Nuru-Jeter, an assistant professor of community health and human development at the University of California Berkeley School of Public Health, said in a university news release. "This study is providing an early warning sign that the decline in disability rates we've been hearing about might be ending."

After analyzing the period from 2000-2005, the researchers found a 9 percent increase in the number of non-institutionalized people aged 65 and older who said they have difficulty handling day-to-day activities, including dressing and bathing, because of a problem lasting six months or more.

"The combination of increasing disability rates, plus a growing population of older adults emphasizes the importance of prevention of the many chronic conditions giving rise to disability in the first place," the study's lead author, Esme Fuller-Thomson, a professor of social work at the University of Toronto, explained in the release. "There is evidence, for example, that the doubling of obesity rates over the last three decades may be linked to rising disability in older people, yet the obesity problem is largely preventable."

The findings are published in the December issue of the Journals of Gerontology.

More information

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has details on preventing disability in the elderly with chronic disease.

(SOURCE: University of California Berkeley, news release, Dec. 21, 2009)

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

US Gov Disability Compendium.

Got a thing for stats? Check out the spanking new US Government report - to be an annual event - on disability. Lots of goodies. Help me digest them!

http://disabilitycompendium.org/

Labels:

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Suffering Is A Gift From God.

From Reflections of a Paralytic:

This is an excellent article from Steve Pokorny at Catholic Exchange. A bit of an intro:

Throughout human history, since Adam and Eve, there has been the temptation to want to take the powers of life into our own hands. There is the insidious idea that is floated through our fallible minds that if we manipulate things to our liking, then things will just go better. Or so we think.

Take the issue of euthanasia that is ramping up its exposure. From a recent Discovery Institute article entitled “Suicide Radicalism Surges in America,” we read that “Doctor” Philip Nischke of Australia “has brought his suicide seminar to California and Washington State, where he taught all comers how they can make themselves dead.” His logic (albeit misguided) leads him to “if we each own our bodies, he says, and if self-termination is an acceptable answer to human suffering, then assisted suicide shouldn’t be restricted to limited “subgroups” such as the terminally ill.”

“Dr. Phil” would be correct if our bodies were merely an instrument, something that is separate from ourselves. Yet this is the same trouble that dear fellow Descartes got himself into.

I don’t want to give too much away here – read the whole thing!


When we suffer, we work to find reasons why. Simply saying that life is suffering is not enough. The fear of death and pain demand that we find reason, justification. If we decide that we are not responsible for our lives, we can pass the responsibility to God. It's easy. He won't give you more than you can handle. You must learn from your pain. Suffering is God's punishment for your sins (as was Christ's) and your blessing.

Yet, not everyone believes this. Our society is pluralistic, of many races, genders, sexualities, income brackets, faiths, and ideas. Assigning our laws to reflect only one of these is discrimination against all others. If democracy can only exist when church and state are separate, the above advocates for a theocracy. And we all know how theocracies work out, right?

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

A Canadian Quadriplegic Addresses Euthanasia Laws.

Steven Fletcher, a Canadian C4 quadriplegic, writes today for the NationalPost that he supports the proposed euthanasia bill there, preferring that patients have a choice to end their pain and suffering, but asks that it not be the only choice:

A critical element that informs our discussion of euthanasia is the level of support that we, as individuals and as a society, provide to people who have reached such difficult crossroads as mine. This means more than just controlling pain and keeping a person alive. The prospect of a good quality of life bolsters the will to live. With proper medical and social assistance, people who want to end their lives often change their perspective about life itself. In my case, my own wish to be euthanized in the time after my accident (suicide by my own hand was not an option, as I was trapped in my body) changed as I began to received more support.

There are situations in which all the resources in the world cannot help. Physical pain cannot always be managed. Sue Rodriguez suffered from a degenerative condition called ALS, or Lou Gehrig’s disease. Doomed to suffocate as her muscles and lungs collapsed, this courageous woman went all the way to the Supreme Court requesting the right to die. She was denied, and chose to commit suicide illegally with the help of an un-named doctor. In a situation such as Sue Rodriguez’s, I support the right to choose death.

When speaking of euthanasia, the metaphor of “the slippery slope” is often raised by the disabled community — the idea being that the mercy-killing of even one person may lead to the wholesale culling of the ranks of the disabled.

But I see the slippery slope going in two directions. In one direction, people could be killed because others think their pain is intolerable — just as disabled advocates claim. But there is another direction, too, whereby people can be forced to live in pain that truly is intolerable.

To be clear, one direction that Canada can never slip down is that of Robert Latimer, who arbitrarily decided to kill his young disabled daughter. This was clearly murder. But other situations are more nuanced.

As soon as I could speak after my accident, I had a lawyer develop a living will. This document explains to my parents and loved ones my wishes. My living will allows the prospect of euthanasia under certain circumstances. Unfortunately, the euthanasia provisions in my living will may not be binding or enforceable, which is why I agree that changes should be considered to our current law. Heaven forbid that the provisions in my living will ever need to be carried out, but if the situation does arise, my wishes may be trumped by the criminal code.

I want to be empowered to make the best decisions for myself; and if I am unable, I want the people who love me to do what they think is in my best interest. I do not want to be forced to live in a hell because the law does not take into account my “unique” circumstances or because someone imposed their values on the meaning of life on me. Given the choice of existence without living or death, I would rather choose the latter and take my chances on the other side.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, October 4, 2009

Disability Rights and the Assisted Suicide Movement.




Opposition to assisted suicide comes from many corners. For me, one of the most emotionally charged factions of opposition is that of the disabled who fear the "slippery slope" disintegration of our culture into a devaluation of those who are born with or develop physical and mental disabilities.

The disability rights movement, building on a California ruling in 1959 for independent living of those diagnosed with polio, blossomed in the 70s - alongside the "euthanasia" movement and the pro-life movement - rooting itself firmly in the civil rights and consumer movements. (The Rehabilitation Act that requires all organizations receiving federal funds to accommodate the disabled was passed in 1973 the same year Roe v Wade was passed.) Many disability rights groups have allied themselves with pro-life groups to contest the abortion of disabled fetuses even as they have worked for individual rights and choice.

Groups like Not Dead Yet, founded in 1996 in response to the assisted suicides of two disabled people by Dr. Jack Kevorkian and galvanized by the case of Terri Schiavo who was removed from nutrition and hydration by court order in 2005, have joined with other disability organizations to oppose the advance of state assisted suicide bills. When a guardian is given the right to remove a disabled person from life-sustaining medical services, as was the case with Terri Schiavo, the disabled community rightly feels threatened. When doctors can accurately predict down syndrome in fetuses, the disabled community finds discrimination in the choice of a mother to abort.

In a 2006 article regarding the Supreme Court's 6-3 decision on Oregon's Death with Dignity law and explaining why the disabled so fiercely oppose assisted suicide, RaggedEdge writes:

One might think that disability rights activists would be strong supporters of the "right to die" -- after all, the independent-living movement's core beliefs -- that people should be able to make their own choices and control their own lives -- seem to be exactly the beliefs that drive right-to-die advocates.

The problem, say disability rights activists, has to do with the society in which we find ourselves -- and society's attitudes.

Life with a disability is so devalued, society is so bigoted against the idea that life with a severe disability can have quality, that in such a climate the "right to die" becomes a "duty to die." Activists fear that people who become disabled will choose suicide over living with disability. They fear that people whose disabilities make them burdens on family members will be pressured -- subtly or not so subtly -- to end their lives.

The definition of "disabled," which includes such disparate physical and mental states as blindness, schizophrenia, down syndrome, paralization, and persistent vegetative state, only complicates the advocacy for disabled rights and its nexus with assisted suicide. As the above quote belies, the determined fight for independence and self-determination that the disabled have long fought seems to contradict the primary justification for the legalization of assisted suicide.

Yet once was the time when the blind feared that eye-corrective surgery would endanger their disability rights by making blindness an at least partially correctable state. The advancement of medical technology has proved a blessing and a curse for disability rights, altering how society views disabilities in a two-steps-forward-three-steps-back manner.

The assisted suicide movement, advance directives, and living wills have produced, over the past 30 to 40 years but most recently with the legalization of death with dignity in three US states and the push to reform health care, an anxiety among the disabled. They fear, even as their rights have been legally protected, that the public continues to devalue life with disability. When an advance directive can prevent a severely disabled person from being placed on life-sustaining medical support, they detect a devaluation of life with disability. Common is the person who expresses the wish to not live in a persistent vegetative state, as the nation's experience of the death of Terri Schiavo proved, or with other disabilities, seeing disability as a diminishment.

Certainly, there is a tone to discourse among the disabled that resembles what Barbara Ehrenreich characterizes in her definitive 2001 article on breast cancer, "Welcome To Cancerland," as glorification of victimhood, survivor status, and persevering through suffering. One can't fault a paraplegic for finding meaning in their disability, yet the prospect of becoming a paraplegic oneself has caused hundreds of thousands of Americans to sign advance directives. How we protect the rights of the disabled in some ways collides with our ability to experience empathy for their conditions. End of life choice and medical advancements brings that collision to the fore of social discourse.

Because the definition of disability is varies greatly, estimates of those in the world living with disability are difficult to make. The World Health Organization estimates that out of a world population of 6.5 billion, 100 million can be considered moderately or severely disabled. In the US, the disabled make up the third largest minority after Hispanics and African Americans.

How we as a society continue to value life with disability, to protect individual rights, and to address the medical industry's regard and treatment of quality of life and end of life issues will determine the level of protection and rights of those with disabilities. The nexus of the assisted suicide movement and disability rights is encumbered with so many other issues like depression treatment, suicide prevention, the pro-life cause, religious rights, and health care reform that it is hard to predict how either advocacy group will proceed.

New Hampshire continues the push for the legalization of assisted suicide with the committee work they are currently doing on a state bill. The challenge is to provide all citizens with rights to life and dignity in death. How we do so will demonstrate our advancement in human rights as a society.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Disability, Suffering and The Illogic of Slippery Slopes.




Disabled groups like Not Dead Yet have been some of the most vocal opponents to the Death with Dignity movement, contending that as one of the most vulnerable groups in society, they will be pushed into hastening their own deaths because they are seen as living lives with less dignity, functionality, and joy than others. Though Death with Dignity, as it exists in Oregon and Washington, is only permitted in the mentally sound, terminally ill and must be self-administered, the disabled fear that their "burden" to society will place them on what they see as the slippery slope diminishment of respect for life demonstrated by the legalization of abortion and aid in dying.


Mark Pickup, a triplegic due to multiple sclerosis and an anti-choice in dying advocate, was a close friend and ally of Robert and Mary Schindler, Terri Schiavo's parents, themselves staunch Catholics and activists against terminating life support of their persistent vegetative state daughter and other "disabled" patients, of which there are some 15,000 in the US at any given time. Pickup writes a farewell on his blog to Robert Schindler, who died of heart failure on August 29th.


While doctors may have ascribed Schindler's death to cardiac arrest, he writes, "those of us who knew Bob know he really died of a broken heart" from not being able to prevent the "murder" of his daughter at the hands of the state and her husband, Michael Schiavo, who "wanted her dead."


Terri did not need to die. Michael had moved on with his life, hooked up with a new woman, and even started a family with her. He was obviously in a conflict of interest regarding Terri Schiavo’s best interests.


The Schindlers wanted to take their daughter home, saying that their desire to love her and care for her demonstrated their superior love and deserved custody. Michael, who contested that Terri would not have wanted to live in a persistent vegetative state, after 15 years won the right to remove feeding and hydration tubes from his wife. She died 13 days later, on March 31, 2005.


I know I'm hashing old ground here - I've written about Terri Schiavo elsewhere - but as I think more about suffering and the role it plays in this argument of "slippery slope," quality of life, responsibility-to-live-despite-all-other-factors that anti-choice in dying groups pose, I found Pickup's post helpful. He writes:


Terri Schiavo had a serious disability but she was not dying. She relied on a feeding tube but did not need a respirator or other means of artificial life support. Terri Schiavo had a normal life expectancy but her husband maintained she would not want to live in such a state of disability. There was no written document from Terri saying this, nor did she complete a living will laying out her wishes. Granted, she probably did not want to live with a disability. Nobody does. So what! I do not want to live with my serious disability but that does not mean I’m better off dead. Millions of people with severe disabilities live happy and vital lives.


All mental and physical afflictions, whether degenerative, terminal, or however extreme, seem to fall into Pickup's one category: disabled. Though there was no chance for Terri to ever emerge from her persistent vegetative state, her life was sacred to her family. We could say that Terri's life could not matter to her in her diminished mental state but that it mattered to her family.


Pickup argues for the sanctity of all lives even as he states that some disabled live happily and vitally and that Schiavo never recorded her wishes to be removed from life support. Quality of life and personal choice are, like Palin's statement that she chose to have a Down Syndrom child though she doesn't believe in choice, used to garner praise or prop up the hope for a miracle recovery. Ultimately, this narrative concludes that it's not the vitality or happiness that makes a life worth living, not the autonomy of humans and the choice to live, but the suffering that one undergoes. That Schindler suffered, that Pickup suffers, that Michael Schiavo loved again and "hooked up" with another woman to avoid suffering; these acceptances or denials of suffering are used to determine one's value. If suffering has a purpose given by God, trying to escape suffering is gonna get you in trouble.


Pickup's blog subtitle is, "Reflections on disability, Christian meaning and purpose in suffering. Christian subjects." As Christian subjects - all of us, regardless of faith - we are given suffering from God and according to his laws must bear that suffering. Only he can end it or end our lives. In other words, as a good parent/lover, God knows what is best for us and gives us suffering if we deserve it. And he gives us no more than we can bear. Church tenets and a judicious patriarchy interpret God's will and govern us accordingly.


The "martyrdom" of Schiavo is retold by Pickup: "Christians and other people of good will gathered outside the hospice to protest the torture and murder of an innocent and defenceless woman, unable to speak or fight for herself." Though doctors concur that Schiavo was unable to sense pain, her family and activists contend that she suffered miserably from dehydration and hunger until her death at the hands of the "culture of death." Her physical suffering - and that of her family and activists - is vital to her martyrdom (and theirs). Suffering is proof of the rightness and worthiness of their cause.


Interspursed with images of Robert Schindler and the Statue of Liberty weeping, Pickup's post reminds us of the role suffering plays in redemption and personal autonomy. Their fight against Death with Dignity (in spite of the fact that it requires self-administering) is a fight for suffering, for what they call the "natural" law of God and His right to cut the thread.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Are the Disabled Ruining Death with Dignity for the Rest of Us?


Advocacy groups for the disabled in the US, like Not Dead Yet, have long allied themselves with anti-choice opponents to assisted dying, their premise being that the dignity or quality of life argument used by death with dignity advocates denigrates their lives.

From Dr. Kevorkian's assisted suicide of two disabled women in 1996, to the case of Terri Schiavo, classified as disabled by her family and religious groups, to the praise showered on Sarah Palin for choosing to give birth to a Down Syndrome baby, some disability rights advocates have long found death with dignity a threat.

Their position is that once it is decided an individual may legally determine when their life ends - and injest a doctor-prescribed lethal dose of drugs - authorities, have defined which lives are worth living. If the disabled feel in any way that society does not value them as they are, these groups say, they will be pushed further into the depression that often accompanies disability or even coerced to end their lives.

Now disabled organizations are firing back at Tony Delamothe, deputy editor of the British Medical Journal, for penning an article titled, "Assisted dying: what's disability got to do with it?" Delamothe writes:

The debate on assisted dying has been hijacked by disabled people who want to live. It needs to be reclaimed for terminally ill people who want to die

In the debate on the Falconer amendment in the House of Lords it was down to that wise old bird, Baroness Warnock, to dispel the sloppy thinking: "I think there is confusion if we run the disabled as a class of people, members of society, into another class of people, the terminally ill, although they may overlap. There are two different concepts, and we should not bring them together under the general heading of the vulnerable about whom we hear, in my experience, all too much." I hope Baroness Warnock lives for ever, although I know that she does not want to.

On first read, Delamothe's article is hard to stomach. His tone is crass and sarcastic. Yet in some ways his argument reminds us of the insecurities felt by the blind when corrective surgeries were being developed.

Writes Peter Singer in "Why We Must Ration Health Care," a discussion about how societies assign value to life, "If life with quadriplegia is as good as life without it, there is no health benefit to be gained by curing it."

Indeed, definitions play a hard role in this discourse. What qualifies as disabled? Down Syndrome? Persistent Vegetative State? Quadriplegia? What is terminal? Expected to die in 3 months? 3 years? And how does a government honor one's personal choice to die while protecting the rights of the vulnerable, the infirm?

Labels: ,